Sir,
Thanks for your reply. When I set the knife up, the stone was only touching the bevel. I did use an up and down scrubbing motion, but the stones never left the bevel that I can recall. I am not sure how the stones left the bevel, but I will take another look. I have gifted the old vice so I no longer have it to compare the height of each vice. I just know that my set-up and sharpening technique has not changed from one vice to another so I am very stumped. Thanks again for your reply!