I happen to have recently done much the same thing on a couple of knives with deep scratches. Generally, the factories are happy to let their knives go out with a scratch pattern of about 220 grit, as long as they’re parallel and vertical. Judging from Barry’s photo, I’m guessing the deepest scratches are from a grit coarser than 220, which would mean that there’s a lot of hand sanding in his future. When hand-sanding large areas, it’s really difficult to remove much steel, even with coarse grits. Imagine trying to remove the scratches on a 4-inch wide bevel with your WEPS.
I have buffing wheels down to 240 grit, but in this case, I’d be inclined to use a 120 grit belt on my 1X30 belt sander, using the platen as a back-up to the belt. Then 180, 220 and 320 before going to the buffing wheels at 400, 600 and on to the true polishing compounds. When doing the lower grits on the buffing wheels, I’ll use the 45L, 90, 45R, 90, 45L pattern to be sure I’d removed all traces of the previous grit. Finish up at 90-degrees to the spine.
When polishing a large area by hand, it’s really easy to create some waviness which will reflect light when fully polished, hence the recommendation to use a platen-backed sanding belt. I might even stay with the belt up to 600 or 800 grit to reduce the chance of creating an uneven surface. If you don’t have a a belt sander, then you should use a sanding block to keep the surface flat.
3 users thanked author for this post.