Case for WE130, upgrade options?
- This topic has 35 replies, 6 voices, and was last updated 11/28/2017 at 6:01 pm by
.
-
Justin, hello and welcome to the Forum. I started with the Pro Pack 2. I too upgraded to make it into the WE130 or Pro Pack 3. I never did try to put it in the case so I can’t answer your case question. I’m sorry to hear your not getting the results you wish to achieve. The WE130 clamp is easier to use and eliminates the clamping tilt associated with the old screw type clamp that came with your Pro Pack 2. The clamp will not give you better results, though. Better results I believe is from time, practice and technique. Everything is the same and done the same, with both systems, except the first step; clamping the knife. So just changing the clamp I’m afraid may not give you better results. The results you should get and expect from the Pro Pack 2 should far exceed what you’ve described, just being like a “free hand” sharpening job.
Maybe if you could share some more about your not impressive edges that we on the Forum may help you with. Your edges should be much more even, acute and shinier than a free-hand sharpened edge. I wouldn’t want you to invest more expecting a drastic difference because used as intended the Pro Pack 2 can deliver a hair popping mirror like edge, repeatedly, at the precise angle of your choosing.
Marc
(MarcH's Rack-Its)2 users thanked author for this post.
Hi Marc,
Thanks for the reply. I suppose I will call in to the shop to get the case question answered.
On the results side, I have tons of trouble with the vise. I don’t want to scratch my knives when clamping them, so I put a piece of aluminum tape on the spine and flat or primary bevel, depending on the knife, then a coat of blue painters tape. I snug the top screw up, and tighten the bottom one, most times if I just gently push the handle of the knife, it will come right out of the vice. Like spin towards me and fall right out. with the edge now facing me. If I tighten it more, the blade starts to tilt off the vertical axis. Then I need to take it out and do it all again. Once I finally get it secure sometimes it’s not in the sweet spot anymore. So it’s a lot of pissing around. Sometimes 15 minutes to get it into final stable position. Then sometimes when I check on it mid sharpen, it’s off axis from vertical again. Sometimes as much as half a degree.
So I can get down to a pretty good mirror polish, but I can’t get them hair whittling sharp. Shaving sharp easily, but not to the point of being able to pass the hanging hair test or similar.
Here are some pics:
The above edge was achieved by hand. I was too frustrated to monkey with the WEPS due to long setup time, and worried about damaging the Damascus…. and had a new leather strop to break in so figured no risk to the rare Damascus and need to work a strop so why not. Also was comfy with a slight convex edge on it.
This one is my latest go on the WEPS, good polish but not particularly sharp compared to the one done by hand. Easily shaves arm hair, but won’t cut hanging hair.Justin, thanks for the additional info. You would find it a great help and relief to clamping issues that you described if you were to upgrade to the WE130 clamp. It is much easier to quickly and securely clamp a knife, open the jaws make an adjustment and reclamp it. You can do it over and over in seconds what takes like forever with the old style clamp. I place a patch of real chamois used dry around the spine and up the sides then insert the knife down in between the jaws. The chamois both protects the steel and compresses under clamping pressure to tightly hold the knife. The new tension adjustor allows you to increase or decrease the tension to adapt for thinner or thicker knives. If a securely clamped knife is the roots of your issue, keeping you from using and enjoying your WE then definitely upgrading the clamp will help you greatly. The new clamp is quick and easy and has taken all the clamping issues and inconvenience out of the Pro Pac 2. Simply said, “I love this new clamp”.
Since you stated you do sharpen distally tapered knives, be sure the upgrade WE130 Vice you purchase comes with the new style split jaws. They were specifically designed for tapered knives. The new vice will remove the hassles and make it enjoyable for you to improve your technique and get great results.
Marc
(MarcH's Rack-Its)2 users thanked author for this post.
Are you still using your original stones? Are the new arms and old stones a bad, sloppy fit?
Justin, the new arms work very well with the old stones. The fit is snugger now with the new arms. I can not tell any difference in feel between the new arms with old stones VS new arms with new stones. All your old stones and strops will work well. Whichever way you choose to go I know you’ll be happy with the WE130.
I’m sorry to hear the old case won’t work. With a new foam insert the old case will be useful for something or to someone. They sell for $150, new.
Marc
(MarcH's Rack-Its)3 users thanked author for this post.
Welcome to the forum, Justin! I also tried the WE130 vise (and I am expecting a permanent one…) and I can confirm it works much easier than the older one. The only thing I find odd is that you are not able to clamp your knives securely in the older vise. I usually only use some painters tape to protect the knife against scratches and if I turn the screws tightly, I am able to lift the entire WE, including the base, by the knife (be careful though!). Are you sure there is nothing wrong with your current vise?
Molecule Polishing: my blog about sharpening with the Wicked Edge
1 user thanked author for this post.
Mark, I think he’s having the problem because he’s dealing with fully flat ground blades. That said, Clay did demonstrate that the old clamp can be used on FFG blades if you add some foam to the upper part of the jaws.
2 users thanked author for this post.
If I sharpen FFG blades, using some chamois works great, no need to add foam.
Molecule Polishing: my blog about sharpening with the Wicked Edge
1 user thanked author for this post.
For me the Gen 3 clamp was a turning point. It really made the WE easy and a pleasure to use. But now with the newer split jaws and tension adjustment it’s really great. Setting up a knife and making multiple adjustments to find the sweet spot or match an existing bevel angle is quick and simple. It’s easier than ever to replicate an edge and match the previous bevel repeatedly, dead-on, on the first try. As long as my sharpening log is explicit I can match the clamping position every time.
Marc
(MarcH's Rack-Its)2 users thanked author for this post.
Thanks Gentlemen. I am going to order the upgrade. Just need to decide on the new L brackets or not.
I should add most of my knives also have a distal taper, in addition to a FFG, so they are hell in the WE100. I suppose some foam or something may help, but that makes for a whole bunch of playing around I don’t want to do. I’ll skip the chamois for now hoping the 130 is sufficient along with some painters tape. Most of the knives I do are expensive as far as my budget goes so it’s important not to damage them.
I look forward to the 130!
1 user thanked author for this post.
Did you verify the 130 comes with the new split jaws. For your distal tapered knives that’s impt.
Marc
(MarcH's Rack-Its)2 users thanked author for this post.
I think you’re going to be pleased with your purchase decision. The single action clamp is a very nice feature and really makes it so you can set up a knife in a matter of seconds. I don’t own any FFG blades, so I can’t comment on how it handles them from personal experience, but the new clamp was designed with these blade attributes in mind, so I think it will improve your sharpening experience significantly.
3 users thanked author for this post.
I did, with Kyle on the phone. I ordered a WE130UP1, so new vice, degree bar and guide rods. But I retain the previous L brackets and ball joints. Do you guys think the new L-brackets and ball joints are worth the $70 upgrade? Based on Kyle’s input, I went with keeping the existing ones. But I’m open to suggestions at this point.
My order MAY ship Friday, but likely not till Monday, so I guess I could still change it if you guys think I ordered the wrong upgrade or something.
I also ordered Glass platens with 6 and 3 lapping films, and the 4/2 micron diamond emulsion and leather strops pack. I will add those two steps between my micro fine ceramics, and my existing 1/.5 micron paste leather strop.
The current progression is diamond up to 1000. Then I switch to 1200/1600 ceramic, Fine and Micro Fine ceramic, now adding in 6/3 lapping, then 4/2 leather strop, and finally 1/.5 leather strop so that each step is fewer passes, and I will end up with a good polish, and a sharper edge.
Any input Gentlemen?
Thanks for all your help!
1 user thanked author for this post.
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.