I totally agree, Tom (and it’s nothing I’d have any interest in) but…
:Additionally the bare aluminum would oxidize without finishing over it, further affecting whatever dubious effectiveness it would have by sharpening.
I don’t think this, in particular, is really an issue. Aluminum bonds with oxygen almost immediately forming Bauxite. It becomes a ceramic “coating” which is pretty resistant to further corrosion, barring exposure to very caustic substances. It’s pretty thin, like one molecule. Yeah, you couldn’t shave with it 😉 , but it’s not going to get eaten away or anything.
Ken